← All book exhibits

THE CONTRARIAN HERD

exhibit

← the mainstream herd the contrarian herd → WE THINK FOR OURSELVES THE CONTRARIAN HERD. Conspiracy theories are groupthink in a cooler jacket. Here's the twist that should make everyone uncomfortable, including me. The people who pride themselves on rejecting the mainstream are often the most perfectly herded people on the internet. Someone notices institutions sometimes lie (they do — see the receipts). They decide to “do their own research.” Their research is the same twelve videos, recommended by the same algorithm, to everyone else doing their own research. Same conclusions. Same phrases. Same supplements. Independent thinkers. All of them. In unison. In 2016, physicist David Grimes modeled how long big conspiracies could stay secret. A faked moon landing, with the hundreds of thousands of people who worked on the space program, would likely have leaked within a few years. Secrets are hard. Herds are leaky. And my favorite proof that the instinct to belong beats the instinct to think: “Birds Aren't Real” started as satire of conspiracy culture — and still picked up people who believed it. A joke about herds got its own herd. The fourth question nobody asks: do I believe this because it's true, or because it makes me feel special? Secret knowledge feels amazing. That feeling is not evidence. When millions of people share the feeling of being one of the few, the math stops working. A herd running away from the herd is still a herd. Contrarian isn't the opposite of herd. Zero is. Interruption: entertain a thought without accepting it. →

The podcast · Launching 2027

Get the first episode in 2027. Better late than never.

By signing up you agree we can email you when the podcast launches. One email, maybe two. Unsubscribe anytime.

Visit the podcast →

The podcast · Launching 2027

Get the first episode in 2027. Better late than never.

By signing up you agree we can email you when the podcast launches. One email, maybe two. Unsubscribe anytime.

Visit the podcast →